Titans and Packers Tarde (denied by Brianeal23)

Last edited by on Sat Sep 22, 2007 7:54 am; edited 1 time in total

Titans get:

Cullen Jenkins, DE-84
Donald Driver, WR-93

Packers Get:

Chris Hope, SS-92
Ben Troupe, TE-81
2008 Titans 3rd round pick (rookie draft)

bbbtalb0 wrote:: Titans get:

Cullen Jenkins, DE
Donald Driver, WR

Packers Get:

Chris Hope, SS
Ben Troupe, TE

Could you post the ratings of all these players?

I posted the ratings.

going on my head from x-box

Titans get:

Cullen Jenkins, DE-82
Donald Driver, WR-94

Packers Get:

Chris Hope, SS-90
Ben Troupe, TE-81

but i don't like this deal for some odd reason

bbbtalb0 wrote:: Titans get:

Cullen Jenkins, DE-84
Donald Driver, WR-93

Packers Get:

Chris Hope, SS-92
Ben Troupe, TE-81

These ratings are right

I do not approve of this trade, the Titans aren't giving nearly enough. Troupe isn't going to get any better at all since Bo Scaife is now going to be the starter there forever and based on expert sportscenter analysis we have seen the best of Ben Troupe already. And Donald Driver is a very, very good WR, and all they are getting is a good, not even great FS. This is not a fair trade.

To make it even, they should both put in players from both the same positions, and then add in a pick or 2 to make it even. Right now, I'm not going to approve, it's an odd trade deal.......

I would agree that the Titans are winning this trade. But i would approve of it because Troupe is still a solid TE and Hope is a solid safety. Driver is a very good WR but he said he wanted defensive help and hes getting that with Hope.

So i would approve this trade.

i think this is trade is close enouph

I dunno, I think the Titans have to add a 2nd round pick and its square

Guest

I reject this trade.

Wait. Hope is only 26 and a 92 at S which is what the pack need. I actually think deal is fair.

3 Trade Mods have and expressed their disliked their feel for this deal. Re-do it guys. Sorry.

well i am not on the coucil and such

but i am iffy on this trade, but it's is approvable

Well the count is 1-2 or 2-2 in favor of denial I believe. So we just have to wait until someone else says no or yes.

Brianeal23 wrote:: Well the count is 1-2 or 2-2 in favor of denial I believe. So we just have to wait until someone else says no or yes.

Sox said No
Zoom said no
and you did as well.

Guest

titans need to give like a 2nd or 3rd rounder

All trade Mods:

Please. Explain if you reject the trade at first sight. Then please proceed to tell what it could use in order to be passed

I think the Titans should either give a WR in the 80's overall wise or give a 1st rounder... but thats just my opinion.

I think titans need to add a 2nd

reasoning for my denial:

WR>SS
DT>TE

I think that when you factor in Driver's age and position that can still overpower hope a bit, hes good dont get me wrong but still, hes a S which is on the latter half of defense importance.