SF 49ers, and GB Packers' Trade Deal (denied)

GB gets :

Tully Banta-Cain [78]

Michael Lewis [84]

Mark Roman [76]

Walt Harris [88]

2nd Round Pick


SF gets :

Brady Poppinga [75]

Nick Collins [80]

Marquand Manuel [74]

Al Harris [95]


P.S. - I agree on this trade deal......

I agree with Sox, GB isn't getting enough here or is giving up too much...you guys figure it out between the 2 of you

He's getting 3 better players than he has now, How is he getting screwed over?!

He's just helping me out on CB like I wanted....

Woow i didnt say anything about a 3rd round pick for you......

We been talking about it for over like 30 minutes. I'm losing more defense than he is because He still has a 90+ CB on his depth.....(Charles Woodson)

MRxINCREDIBLE wrote:

Woow i didnt say anything about a 3rd round pick for you......

Fixed....Sorry about it....

i accept

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

GB gets :

Tully Banta-Cain [78]

Michael Lewis [84]

Mark Roman [76]

Walt Harris [88]


SF gets :

Brady Poppinga [75]

Nick Collins [80]

Marquand Manuel [74]

Al Harris [95]


P.S. - I agree on this trade deal......

No. This isnt even close to fair. Al Harris is one of the top CBs in all of football. 49ers need to add more

Can you please understand that I'm helping him 3 different places, and he's helping me out in one of them......I HAD a solid secondary, now I got an below average safeties.......

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

Can you please understand that I'm helping him 3 different places, and he's helping me out in one of them......I HAD a solid secondary, now I got an below average safeties.......

Its not about helping. You arent doing him a favor by giving him crap foran elite CB as Harris is

DC wrote:

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

Can you please understand that I'm helping him 3 different places, and he's helping me out in one of them......I HAD a solid secondary, now I got an below average safeties.......

Its not about helping. You arent doing him a favor by giving him crap foran elite CB as Harris is

It wouldn't have been fair, If I have taken both of his top CBs. It's even he literally winning this deal 3 - 1, Is not like if he lost alot.....

{ B u m p ' d }

I'd say this is a fair deal, and I approve of it, I think Al Harris is very, very good and is worth the 2nd rounder, Walt harris, and Michael Lewis, then from there everything evens off. I think this trade isn't off enough to be denied so thats why I'm saying yes.

I also approve of this deal.

We need one more trade mod to approve and we can get this locked up.

Still against it.

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

GB gets :

Tully Banta-Cain [78]

Michael Lewis [84]

Mark Roman [76]

Walt Harris [88]

2nd Round Pick


SF gets :

Brady Poppinga [75]

Nick Collins [80]

Marquand Manuel [74]

Al Harris [95]


P.S. - I agree on this trade deal......

This trade doesnt sit well with me at all.

I dont see whats wrong with it. Packers is getting better at every position besides CB and Walt + 2nd round pick is pretty equal to Al Harris especially since Al is getting old.

I approve of this trade since the second rnder was added

Zoom the screwed up part about it is that DC ignored Neal, and Titans, and I guess he didn't wait for you for the approvable, or not just chose to deny this. Please post in my copy of this thread in the Trade Talk section..