Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32

Last edited by on Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:31 pm; edited 2 times in total

Patriots Get: Reggie Bush, Duece McAllister, Jason David

Saints Get: Rudi Johnson, Dan Morgan, Richard Marshall

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 3:06 pm

I agree

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 5:06 pm

I think this shouldn't be approved, Because Dan Morgan is a 88, and He's still kind of young at Age 28 (Probably could turn into a 90 again during the season, but we'll never know), and same thing with Rudi, and same thing with Richie at Age 22, and still has a future in him. Bush, and Deuce [22, and 28] are IMO a great duo to have at the HB position, but They both can't replace Dan Morgan, and Rudi at the same time. This trade is just helping out Dman5, and just jacking DC the whole time, Doesn't seem that the Saints are even trying to help him out anywhere. Jason Craft is a 72, and Is going to keep downgrading from there because of his age (31). For this to go through I think Dman5 will have to give him a replacement for Morgan, and a 1st, and 2nd round pick.

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 5:32 pm

hmmm... idk about this one, I don't think the Saints are not getting a very good deal because IMO Bush is worth more than most 90+ overall RB's such as Rudi Johnson. So in this case I'm going to vote no.

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 5:59 pm

can I just make a deal get done I wanna get rid of bush and I dont care if either of the two is accepted but its a pain trading him and no matter who i'm trading with some will rate him as a 89 and some rate him as a Franchise player so no matter what trade it is it's not gonna be perfect

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 6:20 pm

can I get more mods to check this out

thanks

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 6:21 pm

I'm torn here...I'm really not sure...

its close enough though...I'll approve it

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 6:45 pm

its fine

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 7:41 pm

We need one more vote yes.

Guest

The Saints need to throw something in here. A 91, 89, and an 82 is NOT worth an 89, 89, and a 72. The trade with the first two pieces is even. Either they can take out the third player on each side or the Saints can give a low 80s player instead of Craft or add something with Craft. That will make it fair.

Guest

Ill vote yes, but I'm not a trade mod, I have no say.

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 8:30 pm

I would vote no, but im also not a trade mod.

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Mon Oct 01, 2007 8:33 pm

TiTaN10ViNcE wrote:: I would vote no, but im also not a trade mod.

Your a back-up

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 4:52 am

well this is my point we have 2 votes for no that I need to give more and one vote no that he needs to give more so doesn't that even it out

Guest

Dman5 wrote:: well this is my point we have 2 votes for no that I need to give more and one vote no that he needs to give more so doesn't that even it out

ummm, NO!

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 9:11 am

Dman5 wrote:: well this is my point we have 2 votes for no that I need to give more and one vote no that he needs to give more so doesn't that even it out

Not at all.............

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 12:57 pm

Whats going on here?

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:28 pm

all Im saying is that no matter if I give more or if he gives more noboyds going to be happy and I've been trying to trade Bush. I'm really sick of seeing trades being cancled

Guest

i vote yes

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:29 pm

Dman5 wrote:: all Im saying is that no matter if I give more or if he gives more noboyds going to be happy and I've been trying to trade Bush. I'm really sick of seeing trades being cancled

It hasnt been cancelled. The want you to replace Craft with a better player. Thats all

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:31 pm

I'll give u David, but I dont see the point of it cause his contracts high, and u can pick up just as good of a player for cheaper in FA'cy

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:31 pm

DC wrote:: Patriots Get: Reggie Bush, Duece McAllister, Jason David

Saints Get: Rudi Johnson, Dan Morgan, Richard Marshall

I re-agree

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:33 pm

agree

Guest

I agree

Subject: Re: Patriots/Saints Deal (Approved by GQ) #32 Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:45 pm

I actually thought this was fairer before David was added, but i still think it is approvable.

» Seahawsk/Dolphins Deal (Approved by GQ) #29
» Bills and Saints trade (approved by Brianeal23)#12
» SF 49ers, and OAK Raiders' Trade Deal (Approved by GQ) #26
» Patriots/Panthers (Approved by Brianeal23)#5
» Patriots/Giants Trade (Approved by GQ)#17